MM2 trading problems and the easier way

MM2 Trading Problems Players Keep Running Into (and an Easier Way)

Trading is how most Murder Mystery 2 players build an inventory, and it's also where most of the frustration comes from. Ask anyone who has spent an evening in a trading server trying to land one godly and you'll hear the same handful of problems. Some of them cost you items. Others just cost you time. Here are the ones that come up again and again, what's behind each one, and how buying a specific item from MM2Hub gets around them.

1. Swap tricks and item first deals

The classic MM2 scam happens inside the trade window. Someone puts a valuable weapon in, waits for you to get excited, then pulls it out and drops in a cheaper item that looks similar right before you accept. If you're moving fast, you confirm the wrong trade. Trading guides for 2026 still list this as one of the most common tricks, along with the "give me yours first and I'll send mine after" request, where the second half of the deal never comes.

The MM2 wiki also describes trade window glitches, such as trades that break partway through or menus where neither player can add items. None of that is fun when you're trying to finish a deal with a stranger who might be counting on you getting confused.

2. Fake middlemen

When two players don't trust each other, one of them often suggests a middleman: a third person who holds both sides' items and passes them along. It sounds sensible. The trouble is that the middleman is sometimes a friend of the scammer, or the scammer on a second account, and once your item is handed over it doesn't come back. Guides warn about this specific setup over and over, because it's built to look like the careful option.

3. Value lists that disagree

Nikilis, the developer behind MM2, doesn't publish an official price list. Players rely on community lists instead, mainly Supreme Values and MM2Values. According to the MM2 wiki, Supreme is the more widely used of the two, and the two even measure value differently: MM2Values counts in Seers, while Supreme uses its own value units. Guides regularly point out that the lists can disagree on the same item, especially chromas, and suggest checking more than one before you agree to anything.

That gap gives people room to argue. One player quotes the higher list, the other quotes the lower one, and nobody leaves happy.

4. Lowballing and demand

Even when everyone agrees on a value, demand decides whether a trade actually happens. The wiki lists value as a mix of base value, demand, rarity and stability. A rare item with low demand can sit in your inventory for weeks because nobody wants it at its listed number. So you get lowballed: offers well under value, often with a "take it or leave it" attitude. The flip side is the overpay bait, where an offer looks far too generous and turns out to be setting up a swap or a confusing follow up trade.

5. Dupes and value crashes

Older players still talk about the 2017 duping glitch. The wiki describes how items were copied using alt accounts, how trading was shut down for a while to stop it, and how the market took a long time to settle. High demand items like Corrupt eventually recovered much of their value, while lower demand items such as Handsaw never did. Since late 2021, trading has been limited to players at level 10 or higher, which the wiki says was added as a measure against duping. The lesson most traders took from it is that the value of what you're holding can change fast, for reasons that have nothing to do with you.

6. "Free godly" links

Then there are the offers that arrive in DMs or comments: free godlys, giveaways, a link to claim your prize. Guides are consistent that these are usually after your account login. A real trade never needs your password. Anyone who asks for it, or asks you to log in through their link, is not offering you a weapon.

7. It just takes forever

Put all of that together and the biggest complaint is simply time. Finding someone who has the exact godly you want, who also wants what you have, who agrees with your value list, and who isn't trying something, can take days. It gets harder still with new event items. The Halloween 2026 Ember weapons, the Emberbow, Emberscythe and Embersickle, are exactly the kind of thing everyone wants at once, which pushes demand and asking prices up in trading servers.

How MM2Hub handles each of these

We built MM2Hub for players who want the item and don't want the haggling. Here's how it lines up against the list above.

  • Set prices. Every item has one listed price on the site. There's no value list to argue over and nobody to lowball you.
  • You pick the exact item. Browse godlys, knives or the new Halloween items, including the Ember weapons and their chromas, and choose the one you want.
  • Username only. You type your Roblox username on the product page. We never ask for your password, and you never log in anywhere for us.
  • Check out with PayPal. You pay at checkout, then your order page opens so you can follow your order and chat with us.
  • Friend request, then trade. We send you a Roblox friend request. Accept it, then accept our trade in MM2. Most trades happen within a few hours of payment, whenever we're online.
  • A real person in the chat. Your order page has a live order chat, so if you have a question about timing or your username, you can ask us directly.

Because you're getting an item from us in a normal trade, there's no middleman in the picture and no second half of a deal to wait on.

MM2 trading problems and how MM2Hub handles them, an MM2Hub infographic

Where to start

If you're not sure what you want yet, the best selling collection shows what other players pick most. If you'd rather start small, the cheap MM2 items are a good way to see how an order works before you go after a big godly. And if it's your first order, use the code WELCOME10 at checkout for 10% off.

Two quick tips before you buy. Copy your username straight from your Roblox profile, since a capital I and a lowercase l look almost the same. And make sure your account is at level 10, because MM2 won't let a trade through below that.

FAQ

What is the most common scam in MM2 trading?

The swap trick is one of the most common. A player shows a valuable item in the trade window, then switches it for a cheaper look alike right before you accept. Always check every item in the window before you confirm.

Why do MM2 value lists show different values?

There's no official price list from the developer, so players use community lists like Supreme Values and MM2Values. They use different units and update at different times, so the same item can show different numbers.

Do I need to give MM2Hub my Roblox password?

No. We only need your Roblox username. The item arrives through a normal in-game trade after you accept our friend request.

How do I pay at MM2Hub?

Check out on the site with PayPal, and your order page opens. First orders get 10% off with the code WELCOME10.

How fast do I get my item?

Most trades happen within a few hours of payment, whenever we're online. You can check on your order any time through the live chat on your order page.

Keep reading

Back to blog